How Do I Know If I Need a Simple or Surgical Tooth Extraction?
20 Jul 2025
No one loves the idea of having a tooth taken out — but sometimes, it’s the most sensible way to keep your mouth healthy and comfortable. Whether it’s a wisdom tooth causing trouble or a damaged tooth that can’t be restored, a gentle tooth extraction can ease discomfort and prevent further issues.
When your dentist talks you through the process, you’ll usually hear one of two terms: simple or surgical. But what’s the difference and how do you know which one applies to you?
Here’s a clear and reassuring look at both options, so you’ll know what to expect and feel confident in your care.
Simple Tooth Extraction: The Easiest Option
A simple tooth extraction is just that – simple and low-stress. It’s used when the tooth is visible in the mouth and can be removed in one piece without any extra steps.
Your dentist will gently numb the area before carefully easing the tooth out. There’s no need for stitches or cutting, and the whole appointment is usually over in less than an hour. Most people find the process straightforward, and any discomfort is mild and short-lived.
Surgical Tooth Extraction: A Bit More Involved, Still Routine
Sometimes, a bit more care is needed. If a tooth is stuck under the gum, broken below the surface or growing at an awkward angle (as is often the case with wisdom teeth), a surgical tooth extraction is might be the best route.
This simply means your dentist or oral surgeon will make a small opening in the gum to reach the tooth safely. In some cases, the tooth is removed in sections to keep things gentle on surrounding areas.
While it may sound more complex, this kind of extraction is very common and handled with care. You’ll be fully numbed and kept comfortable throughout — and your dental team will guide you through every step, including aftercare.
How Your Dentist Decides
Your dentist will always carry out a thorough assessment before deciding on the best type of tooth extraction.
This usually involves X-rays to check the position, condition and shape of the tooth and its roots. Some of the things they’ll consider include:
- Whether the tooth is visible and has come through properly
- If there’s any damage or decay below the surface
- The shape and length of the tooth’s roots
- Whether the tooth is impacted or close to the jawbone
- Your overall dental and medical health
Once they’ve reviewed everything, your dentist will talk you through your options and explain what’s recommended in simple, easy-to-understand terms.
When Each Type Is Typically Used
Simple tooth extractions are usually done for:
- Teeth with surface-level damage that need to be removed
- Loose adult teeth, often caused by gum issues
- Baby teeth that haven’t come out on their own
Surgical extractions may be recommended for:
- Wisdom teeth that haven’t fully emerged
- Broken or cracked teeth under the gum
- Teeth with curved or complex roots
- Teeth surrounded by bone
- Cases where infection persists despite treatment
What to Expect Afterwards
Whether your tooth extraction is simple or surgical, rest is always important afterwards. You’ll be given clear aftercare instructions to follow at home, and most people feel back to normal in a few days.
Simple extractions often have a quick recovery, usually within 2–3 days. Surgical extractions might need a bit more time, but most people feel comfortable again within a week.
Helpful tips for healing include:
- Avoid smoking and drinking through straws for a couple of days
- Stick to soft foods and avoid anything crunchy or spicy at first
- Rinse gently with salt water after 24 hours
- Take any recommended pain relief if needed
Soreness is normal, but you shouldn’t feel major pain. If anything feels unusual, your dentist is only a phone call away.
What Can You Eat After a Tooth Extraction?
You won’t be tucking into a roast dinner straight away, but there are plenty of soft, nourishing options for the first couple of days. Think yoghurt, soup, mashed potatoes and scrambled eggs.
As your mouth heals, you can gradually return to your usual meals. The key is to go gently and avoid anything that could irritate the area while it’s settling down.
Will You Need to Replace the Tooth?
If the tooth that’s been removed is at the back and doesn’t affect your bite, your dentist may suggest leaving the space. But if the gap affects chewing or is visible when you smile, there are several great options for replacing it:
- Dental implants – a long-term, natural-looking solution
- Bridges – supported by the neighbouring teeth
- Dentures – removable, for one or more missing teeth
Your dentist will go over the choices with you, helping you weigh up comfort, cost and what will suit you best in the long run.
Knowing What to Expect Makes All the Difference
Tooth extractions are more common and more gentle than most people think. With clear information, modern techniques and personalised care, they can be managed easily and with minimal fuss.
Understanding whether you need a simple or surgical tooth extraction is just the start, and your dentist will be with you every step of the way.
Clear Guidance, Personalised Care
Every smile is different and so is every treatment. If you need a tooth extraction or just want to explore your options, we’ll talk you through your options clearly. Just honest advice and a plan that works for you.
If you’re ready to take the next step, book a consultation with Beautiful Smiles. We’re here to help you make informed decisions about your oral health, with care that fits around you.
Back to Blog
